Closed for 23 years.

Now we're back!

Known for the thinnest crust pizza in Port Washington, and famous for our garbage pie. Classic Italian American food. Everything is homemade from lasagna to meatballs, chicken cutlet to tiramisu, you name it it's all made fresh here at Andy's.


Did you know?

We have a full liquor license and are serving beer, wine, and liquor!

Also, please note that we are now CASH ONLY with an ATM on premise.

Plenty of Open Space

Have your next
Event here at Andy's

We have 3 open air patios, plenty of room, & everyone feels like family when they come to Andy's.
Have your next event with us, whether it's a birthday party or event celebration you won't regret hosting at Andy's.

Please call 516-883-0034 to plan your next event.

Our Signature Dishes

We don't skip on ingredients. We buy and use the freshest products on the market. Peppers, onions, mushrooms, veal, chicken, chop meat - you name it, its fresh here at Andy's. And all our sauces are homemade!

Follow us on Insta



Based on 28 reviews

DeMeo Chris
DeMeo Chris
June 1, 2022.

Grew up coming to this place. It has never changed and remains phenomenal. The pizza, the service-----everything.

Jeff Stone
Jeff Stone
May 26, 2022.

The pizza at Andy's is exceptionally delicious, especially the "Garbage Pizza". The staff are always friendly and courteous. Jeff S.

Alan Teitel
Alan Teitel
March 14, 2022.

Just a good pizza and more. I am looking forward to my pizza fixes all summer!

Katherine Hernandez
Katherine Hernandez
February 27, 2022.

The best pizza I have ever try, so fresh and delicious. The seafood dishes were amazing.The service was amazing and the owner made you feel like you are at home. Who ever has been here before, what’s your opinion?

February 12, 2022.


Ace T
Ace T
November 10, 2021.

My wife and I had a great time. Delicious food, and we got some Halloween candies on the way out. The owner was very pleasent.

Previous Next
Test Caption
Test Description goes like this